Among the many causes of
existential anxiety, UFOs and extraterrestrial life have captured considerable attention over the last several years.
Some experts believe that humanity is on the cusp of a major paradigm shift
as they anticipate the disclosure of intelligent, extraterrestrial life. This disclosure, some say, could challenge and
even undermine many Christian beliefs.
Though many conservative Christians believe that UFOs and extraterrestrials are likely associated with the demonic realm, Catholic thinkers have taken a more open view. A
Catholic priest
was recently removed from his position for suggesting that UFOs are a
demonic manifestation (see, Eastern Orthodox response).
The Eastern Orthodox Church takes no
official position on UFOs or extraterrestrial life. Nevertheless, virtually all books and
articles on this topic by Orthodox Christians (including clergy) regard UFOs as
a type of demonic deception intended to sow confusion and ultimately undermine
Christianity. This view is also held by
many Evangelicals.
There are notable exceptions to
this trend. According to one article,
Russian Orthodox theologian, Vladimir Lossky (1903–1958), said that
extraterrestrial life was likely.
“Lossky went as far as to say Christianity might have been meant for
Earth and not necessarily aliens. Meanwhile, in 1965, the well-known American
theologian Reverend John Romanides wrote an op-ed stating Orthodoxy would be
open to the possibility of aliens, with the only question being how close or
far away they were in their relationship to God… The rare modern-day exception
to ‘aliens are demons’ is Father
Maggos, a priest at a Greek Orthodox parish in New York, who states aliens
are possible because God can do whatever God wants.”
In support of the demonic view,
most Orthodox writers invoke the Fathers of the Church, as well as more recent
saints, especially, Fr.
Seraphim Rose. As one article
(see graphic) opines, “Four Orthodox Christian saints…all said the same thing
about the UFO phenomenon decades before the world’s governments started taking
it seriously. They were not guessing.”
According to proponents of the demonic interpretation, the modern UFO phenomena
match the patristic descriptions of demonic aerial activity. In the words of Fr.
Seraphim Rose, “The multifarious demonic deceptions of Orthodox literature
have been adapted to the mythology of outer space, nothing more” (see chart,
below).
In addition to the witness of the
Fathers, critics warn
that the UFO phenomena is often entangled with anti-Christian religious beliefs
associated with the occult and Eastern mysticism (higher
consciousness, pantheism, etc.). There are also numerous testimonies of
so-called alien
abductions which corroborate the belief that extraterrestrial beings are
cruel and malevolent, if not demonic.
Moreover, according to reports over the years, UFOs frequently produce
deleterious physical and even psychological effects when they come into contact
with, or in proximity to, people.
The sudden appearance and departure
of UFOs, especially their disruption of military
bases and operations, is an apparent attempt to manipulate our perceptions and
beliefs by creating confusion, anxiety, and fear. Their strategy is not one of stealth or
surveillance, but to be seen. Such
behavior is not consistent with the idea that these beings are benevolent or
desire to communicate with us. This
evidence does not prove that UFOs are a demonic phenomenon, but it does suggest
that they are potentially malicious and may pose a threat to humans.
There is also important physical
evidence that weighs against the demonic theory. First, though many UFO sightings can be
characterized as ethereal "lights in the sky" (especially at night)
reminiscent of an ‘aerial’ spiritual manifestation, we now have countless, daytime
images and videos of solid, metallic craft that have been viewed with infrared
cameras and detected remotely by radar.
Are we to suppose that demons have (or need) aerospace technology?
To my knowledge, there is no clear
example in Scripture of demons materializing or manipulating matter in such a
way. Some would argue that since angels
can take on human form (Gen 18:1-8, 19:1-3, Heb 13:2, etc.) and even function
as humans (e.g., by eating food), demons have similar powers (some cite Gen
6:1-4). They can, as the pseudepigraphal
book of 1 Enoch (chs. 6-8) suggests, use and manipulate technology for evil
purposes (1 Enoch 8, shown here, is a third century BC interpretation of Gen 6:1-4). The powers attributed to demons, then, would
need to include the ability to produce complex and technologically advanced
solid metal vehicles (some being enormous in size) and propel them through the
atmosphere at fantastic speeds. On use
of 1 Enoch in the NT, see Jude
6, 14-15, 2
Pet 2:4.
The second objection to the demonic
theory is the alleged recovery of alien bodies from UFO crash sites. This claim, made in 2023 during Congressional
testimony, would be worthy of dismissal if it hadn’t come from a
high-ranking member of the Pentagon's UAP Task Force. Unlike humans, who possess both a material
and immaterial nature which allows the spirit to separate from the body upon
death, demons are angel-like beings who possess only one, immortal nature. This spiritual nature can, perhaps, project
itself as a material body, but it cannot be divided from that body (this could
only happen if it took possession of a host body). The demonic theory would require us to
believe that demons are or can become mortal, bipartite beings, or that in
their bodily deaths they cease to exist.
This may be possible, but it seems to defy everything we know about
demons and angels from Scripture.
The enigma of UFOs and
extraterrestrials may not be amenable to a monolithic interpretation. Perhaps there are more than one alien
species, as evidenced by the various shaped vehicles and
the widely varying descriptions of their bodily
appearance. Perhaps, as fallen
creatures, different species manifest different moral behaviors ranging from
cruel to benevolent. If this supposition
is true, a malevolent species could, indeed, exhibit demonic behavior, using
their advanced technology to commit acts of evil and deception. Other species might be more benign.
Some researchers hypothesize that
these beings may not be extraterrestrial at all. French astronomer, Jacques
Vallee, believes that the evidence points to interdimensional beings, that
is, non-human intelligences that coexist with humans, but may be hidden in the unexplored realms or dimensions predicted by Quantum Physics and String Theory. At one
level, this hypothesis dovetails
with the demonic theory above. However,
Valle believes these beings are technologically-based, interdimensional life
forms, rather than supernatural entities that can operate without such
instrumentality.
Affirming the reality of
extraterrestrial or interdimensional beings, leaves unanswered a number of
theological questions regarding their place in creation, their religious
beliefs, and their relationship to Christ’s redeeming work which is cosmic in
scope. Are they created in God’s image,
or are they merely a super-advanced form of tool-making
animals without a spirit? In a forthcoming article, I will discuss these issues, as well as concerns that the disclosure of extraterrestrial beings will necessitate a paradigm shift in Christianity.
As Christians, our response
to these potential threats is to guard against deception (1 Thess 5:21), stay close to the Church, and maintain the spiritual disciplines by continuing in worship, receiving the sacraments, praying daily, practicing humility, reciting the Jesus Prayer, fasting, and confessing our sins.
William DiPucio, Ph.D., teaches courses in religion, astronomy, and nuclear science at an Eastern Orthodox school.
Additional Sources:
- An Orthodox Christian Understanding of Things ‘Not of This World
- Book: The UFO Deception: An Orthodox Christian Perspective, by Fr. Spyridon Bailey
- Video: The UFO Deception: An Orthodox Christian Perspective by Fr. Spyridon Bailey
- Podcast: Orthodoxy and UFOs: What are Orthodox Christians to think of this Phenomenon?
- Excerpts from Orthodoxy and the Religion of the Future, by Father Seraphim Rose
- Catholic: Paul Thigpen’s historical overview of the topic, and his more extensive white paper
- Evangelical: Angels, Demons, and UFOs, by P. C. Scherer, PhD